"Strong . . . Yet Vulnerable" refuses to die
Here are the first compelling bits:
I've noticed something, gentle reader. I've noticed that, in these presumably enlightened but beneath the surface painfully stifling times, people can't stand to describe a woman as "strong" or otherwise capable without throwing in the inherent weakness that they all possess--their vulnerability. I've been noticing it for years, and it shows no sign of going away. . . . It gets even worse when you consider the actual definition of "vulnerable." Web 10 defines it as: Capable of being physically wounded; open to attack or damage; . . .
So anyway, I'm gathering information about the Neko Case show coming up and I innocently go to one of the top 3 Google web sites and come across this nugget:
"In 1997, Case recorded her solo debut, The Virginian, a traditional country album that revealed The Voice--rough around the edges but possessing a vulnerable strength and range that has caused critics and her growing legion of loyal fans to swoon ever since." [Italics are mine, in anger.]
Now, Ms. Case has a voice that is truly impressive. Imagine if Bjork and Annie Lennox had a voice box and that voice box preferred to sing haunting alt country ballads and full-on piledrivers. It would be awesome, right? It is! And you would never think to describe it as "vulnerable."
I realize I'm well on the way to being accused of being too sensitive, but 1. This doesn't keep me up at night even though 2. it's a well-documented epidemic revealing the misguided notion that women and only women, despite their gains, are still but a second away from crying, fainting, or both. I should write an article about it for Slate or something. A couple of weeks ago I was reading about yet another girls-kick-ass type of gal, and found my concentration totally blown by the insertion of that lunatic phrase. If only I could remember who it was! Ah, the vulnerability of a woman's mind.
p.s. Just wanted to see what else was out there. Here are 4-in-a-row from google:
... the belligerent dealer is testament to an unyielding director, who wants astrong, yet vulnerable female character, willing to make the ultimate sacrifice.www.iofilm.co.uk/printer_friendly. php?filename=blind_spot_2002.shtml - 4k - Cached - Similar pages
The Silence Of The Lambs (1991)Foster's strong, yet restrained, vulnerable female lead role in the much talked-aboutfilm was intensified by public knowledge of her real-life associations ...www.filmsite.org/sile.html - 40k - Jun 11, 2005 - Cached - Similar pages
washingtonpost.com: Chatological Humor"W. attracts all of us loyal, devoted, strong yet vulnerable, affectionate womenwho lavish him with attention way beyond what he deserves. ...www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/ liveonline/style/funnyyoushouldask/ - Similar pages
Joan of Arc (1999/I) (TV)Her Joan is strong, yet vulnerable, and Sobieski's ability to capture thecomplexities of the character is what makes her so good, and makes her Joan so ...www.imdb.com/title/tt0178145/ - 52k - Cached - Similar pages
1 Comments:
At last! Someone exposing the outrage that continues to plague the womenfolk of Amerika. I share your concern with the twisted hang-up on strength. Whatever happened to "helpless yet saucy" women, "weak but va-va-voom! girls", or my favorite...oh, never mind, I can't say that here.
Post a Comment
<< Home